Wait, it’s illegal to NOT hit a batter?



st1\:*{behavior:url(#ieooui) }

/* Style Definitions */
{mso-style-name:”Table Normal”;
mso-padding-alt:0in 5.4pt 0in 5.4pt;
font-family:”Times New Roman”;}

If Major League Baseball takes action against White Sox
pitcher Bobby Jenks for throwing behind the Rangers’ Ian Kinsler it will be
just another step in a long line of removing power from pitchers and giving
hitters one more reason to dig and crowd the plate.  Jenks admitted that he had intentionally
thrown behind Kinsler in Saturday night’s game to send a message that he didn’t
like Texas pitchers hitting his
teammates.  Kinsler was not hit and Jenks
proceeded to induce a pop out and finish the game.  Jenks was simply trying to convey that he’ll
defend his teammates and retaliate in kind when they’re disrespected.  This has been part of the game of baseball
since Abner Doubleday started drawing up the rules.  However, in recent years numerous crackdowns
have always sided with hitters and continue to weaken pitchers’ ability to
defend themselves and stick up for their teammates.


I am not in favor of headhunting or deliberately trying to
take a guy’s head off, but pitching inside is part of the game of baseball and
if pitchers are unable to do so hitters will become more and more comfortable
and pitchers will become more vulnerable. 
Ever since the lowering of the mound 40 years ago, pitchers have
consistently been forced to adapt to rules changes and an evolution of the game
that has been exclusively pro-offense. 
Among the evolutions are better bats, harder balls, steroids, protective
armor and smaller parks.  These changes,
though not legislated by MLB, have led to a constant increase in offensive
firepower with no offsets to aid the pitchers. 


Additionally, MLB has instituted rules that have hurt
pitchers even more.  Umpires, under the
orders of MLB, now routinely warn both dugouts after a single batter is hit that
any retaliation will result in automatic ejection for both the pitcher and
manager.  However, umpires do not enforce
these rules with any consistency, and often the only result is that pitchers
are hung out to dry, unable to pitch inside with authority, lest they be
ejected by an umpire with an itchy trigger finger.


The ejection is no deterrent to a pitcher or manager who
wants to protect his team.  Hitters are
regularly plunked following bench warnings as pitchers consider the respect of
their teammates more important than avoiding an ejection.  The real result is that pitchers must
avoid the inner half of the plate and hitters, secure in the knowledge that the
warning is in effect, crowd the plate and dive toward the outer half.  What’s worse, the bench warning rule puts
umpires in a terrible position to determine “intent” on any pitch that comes
close to a hitter.  I’ve seen pitchers
ejected automatically for hitting a batter with an 82 mph curveball.  Anyone who’s played the game at a level
beyond T-ball understands you don’t hit a guy with a curveball if you want to
send a message, but either umpires don’t understand the rule or they don’t
understand the game, either scenario is a bad thing for MLB.  Why not let the players sort things out like they always have?


In this instance, though, Jenks didn’t even hit
anybody.  He merely was trying to show
that he’s sick of his teammates being drilled. 
He wanted the Rangers to know that if they want to continue they can
anticipate an upper 90s fastball in the ribs.  This is the way the game should be
played.  There is no better deterrent to
reckless and dangerous actions than the fear of “getting yours.”  This is one reason I’m a staunch opponent of
the designated hitter.  If pitchers have
to face the music themselves every three innings, they’ll think twice about
dotting a guy’s head.  Since the DH isn’t
going anywhere, the next best target is a team’s best hitter.  If a pitcher doesn’t have to worry about his
own ribs getting smashed, he’ll definitely want to ensure that he doesn’t have
a clubhouse full of guys taking his medicine for him.  If MLB would allow the players to police
themselves, much the way NHL enforcers keep
star players from being cheapshotted, they’ll be able to keep the order.  Violators of the “code” are dealt with
accordingly.  These vain attempts to
control the game and ensure civility are clearly implemented by those who have
no understanding of how things work within the game and among teams.


If a hitter shows up a pitcher he should expect to have
things handled on the field.  If a
pitcher, however, decides to go rogue and headhunt, he’ll either have to answer
for it himself (NL) or hang his teammates out to dry (AL).  In either case, he’ll shape up quickly or his
teammates will ensure that he does.  This is how things were handled for decades
and it should be allowed to continue.  The idea that MLB needs to play the role of hall
monitor is silly.  An ejection or fine
means nothing to these guys.  Their
personal health and safety and their teammates’ respect will change their
behavior quickly. 


If MLB fines or suspends Jenks for NOT hitting a batter, it will be just the latest in a decades long
attempt to reign in a natural part of the game and will only serve to make
hitters that much more eager to get to the plate.  It’s another case of trying to “protect”
hitters, you know, the guys with helmets, elbow guards, and big clubs in their
hands.  The irony is that all this
legislation actually puts pitchers in more danger than anybody.  Line drives come off a bat at well over 100
mph toward a pitcher standing about 55 feet away after his follow through and
he’s not wearing a helmet or any of the ridiculous armor that Barry Bonds made
popular.  We’ve already seen numerous
guys nearly killed in such scenarios and the more MLB caters to hitters and removes
the possibility that they’ll be in any way inconvenienced in their attempt to
tear the cover off the ball; the more likely we are to see pitchers get
drilled, figuratively and literally.


If a pitcher throws at someone’s head simply because he doesn’t like a
guy or he is mad that he just gave up a 450-foot home run, he should be
disciplined, and the league should make an effort to protect players from
deliberate injury.  Fines and suspensions
are merited for brawls and deliberate attempts to injure.  However, to punish a pitcher for sticking up
for his team, and to remove the players’ ability to handle things themselves on
the field hurts the integrity of the game. 
Jenks’ intent wasn’t to injure.  He
meant to miss and he did so very effectively. 
He intended to let the Rangers know he didn’t like their behavior and
that there were consequences for disrespecting his guys.  Bud Selig needs to allow the game to take
care of itself.  It has worked for
decades and the unclear, artificial, inconsistent rules that MLB has tried to
enforce clearly do not.  We need to let things be taken care of between the lines, Biblical style; an eye for an eye, or a rib for a rib.

One comment

  1. leaders06@hotmail.com

    Great take Goodtimes. As anyone who has witnessed a line drive hit to the face of a pitcher knows, there is no more violent injury in sports. And yet, it’s these poor hitters we worry about. In an interview with Bob Costas about a year ago, Mike Schmidt stated that despite small parks and steroids, the “big change” from his era is how “comfortable” today’s hitters are in approaching home plate. Schmidt went on to say something to the effect that “we never approached home plate and dug in “totally comfortable” but rather were always aware that we could end up on our butts at any time—with no appologies offered. Let the players police the game and live by the”code” It worked for years.

Leave a Reply to leaders06@hotmail.com Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s